Auxtail · Case study

Thanks for Visiting

Reach out

Context0%

0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%

Auxtail

StartUp Exp

Context

Short version · ~13 min read

ClientAuxtail Ltd
RoleResearch & Strategy
DeliverableCommercialisation plan
Scope
Market researchPESTLEPorter's Five ForcesJobs to be DonePrimary researchMarket sizingPricingGo to marketBusiness modelInvestor deck

A patent, a founder, and no idea yet whether anyone would buy it.

The problem was never the engineering. Craig Broadbent spent 20 years designing towbars at Nissan and the patent was granted. Nobody had asked whether anyone would pay for it, at what price, or through whom.

My solution was to stop selling a rack and sell a system, priced off the value delta rather than the shelf, over 4 decisions that each name what being right costs. The output is a phased commercialisation strategy and the investor deck that carries it, from an MSc dissertation with Auxtail as the industrial partner. The outcome is not in yet: this is a plan, not a product in driveways.

£44M
UK market for EV owners who cycle and carry bikes, sized bottom up
23
People heard from directly: 20 survey responses and 3 expert interviews
4 of 4
Validation thresholds met, all 4 written down before the survey went out
15%
Lift in adoption intent once the range case was put to the same people
£1,495
Launch price, argued from the value delta rather than from the shelf
18 months
From first units in driveways to the OEM conversation, in 3 gated phases
A silver BMW i4 parked at a kerb beside a park, with the Auxtail rack extended behind it carrying 4 mountain bikes upright and clear of the bodywork.

The rack industry is still designing for petrol

01Market dynamics

Every UK rack was designed around a petrol car. An EV changes 3 things at once: drag costs range, the towbar is capped, and buyers care how it looks.

Roof racks
+26%

Aerodynamic drag added by a roof-mounted carrier, and an EV pays for drag in range

Rear racks
~5%

Efficiency lost to a conventional towbar rack, before you have loaded anything

Towbar ceiling
70kg

European limit on a rear-mounted system, with a 300mm cap on how far it may extend

What is left
2 e-bikes

A rack weighs 17kg to 20kg of that ceiling, and an e-bike is around 25kg

The outside world, by PESTLE
PPolitical
£2 billion went into cycling and walking from 2020 to 2025, and the Cycle to Work scheme covers racks.
So: A tax advantaged way in
EEconomic
The rack market grows about 5% to 7% a year, while rising living costs squeeze what people spend.
So: Price on value, for buyers who can pay
SSocial
Over half the UK lives within a mile of a cycle route, and 88,000 bikes were stolen in England and Wales in 2019/20.
So: Security sells
TTechnological
Premium racks are adding automated locks and connected features, and Thule bought Quad Lock to move that way.
So: Room for app connected locks later
EEnvironmental
Net Zero names active travel, and an aerodynamic accessory can add 2% to 3% to an EV's range.
So: Prove the aero, then market it
LLegal
A rear rack must keep the plate and lights visible or the insurance is void, and UKCA has replaced CE.
So: Compliance becomes a selling point
Where the money already isPerceptual map

Perceived use value

Perceived value

Sells at

£1,495 to £1,795

Where it has to land

Rear wake integration, install once, compliance pack, up to 4 bikes

What it still has to prove

Unproven. No units in customers' hands, and OEM approval is years of testing away

How big, worked out from the bottom upPoint at a ring

TAM 1.1M BEVs, 23.67% own bikes, 20% carry them by car, at £850. Ring areas are drawn in proportion to the figures.

Bottom up from 1.1 million UK battery EVs, the 23.67% of them who own bikes, the 20% who carry bikes by car, at an £850 average selling price. Cross checked top down against UK and European rack industry reports.

Who is inside the £44M2 launch targets
  • LargeLaunch target

    Active families with an EV

    Families in urban or suburban areas who regularly commute hybrid.

    • Reduced range
    • Loading and unloading
    • Design conscious
    • Parking and manoeuvring
    • Theft
  • Medium

    Outdoor leisure travellers

    Cyclists who combine EV travel with weekend or holiday riding.

    • Long distances
    • Reduced range
    • Weather
    • Several bikes at once
  • MediumLaunch target

    Club and group riders

    Adults who ride at events and group rides, and drive there in an EV.

    • Several bikes at once
    • Reduced range
  • Small

    Professional cyclists and triathletes

    Athletes whose specialised bikes need care on the way to an event.

    • High value bikes in weather and over distance
    • Theft

The 2 launch targets are the early adopters the SOM counts, and the people the survey went to.

The Five Forces said it from the other end: rivalry is high, substitutes are everywhere, and still nobody solves drag, install effort and EV looks together. Not a missing category. A missing answer inside a crowded one.

Then I went and asked

02Primary research

Desk research proves a gap exists, not that anyone minds. So the second half ran as a Lean Startup loop: 4 thresholds set in advance, 20 EV owning cyclists surveyed, 3 experts interviewed, and failing any one meant changing the positioning, not the evidence.

The job, stage by stageMarked: found in the research

Transport multiple bicycles securely and efficiently with an electric vehicle in the United Kingdom.

    01Define

    Unsure an EV can carry more than 2 bikes, or what the weight does to range.

    02Locate

    Few racks made for EVs, unclear fit, and reviews scattered everywhere.

    03PrepareInstallation

    Complex fitting, tools, and the risk of marking the car.

    04ConfirmSecurity

    Heavy e-bikes are hard to secure, and nothing shows they are.

    05ExecuteRange

    Range drops, drag rises, and the car handles differently.

    06MonitorSecurity

    Stopping to check the bikes, and worrying about theft.

    07Modify

    Adjusting on the road without the tools or the know how.

    08ConcludeInstallation

    Scratched paint, and a rack that takes long to come off.

Mapped before the survey went out. The marked stages are where the survey and interviews found the same pain. Looks and warranty matched 2 emotional jobs: take pride in how it fits the EV, and protect the car's long term value.

What came up, and how oftenSurvey, 20Interviews, 3
  • Range preservationHigh17 of 23
  • Installation effortHigh14 of 23
  • Warranty concernsLow13 of 23
  • Security, anti theftMedium11 of 23
  • Aesthetic integrationMedium11 of 23
  • Installation accessMedium10 of 23
  • Price resistanceMedium to low8 of 23
Set in advance, then tested4 of 4 met
  • 01 · Survey and interviews

    3 outcomes reach top quartile importance

    Range, installation and security did

  • 02 · Survey, cross checked against Bike Europe

    Modal willingness to pay matches the £1,500 to £1,800 band

    It did, and matches premium rack pricing

  • 03 · Survey, same respondents

    Adoption intent improves by 10% to 15% once the aero case is shown

    6 people moved from maybe to yes, a 15% lift

  • 04 · Automotive, investment and retail interviews

    Experts confirm an OEM or direct to consumer route is feasible

    Both confirmed, with conditions

Three experts, three conditionsYes, if
  • Automotive design

    Rear hardpoint integration is technically possible.

    Adoption depends on documented compliance for lighting, plate visibility and load limits, plus empirical aero and structural data. Test results, not opinions.

  • Mobility investment

    The category is fundable.

    Show acquisition, pre orders and unit economics before going near an OEM. Use financing to take the price barrier down early.

  • Cycling retail

    Families and e-bike owners will want this.

    Centralised installation is the operational problem. Build a regional installer network, and get into the tax advantaged cycling schemes.

The unexpected finding was warranty. 12 of 20 named it, and it is not about the rack: they fear that bolting anything to a new EV voids the cover on the car. That made compliance part of the product, which is why the pricing below sells it rather than footnotes it.

Sell it as a system, not as a rack

03Positioning, price

Sold as a rack, it fights Thule on price and compatibility, which a patent does not win. So the value curve gets rebuilt: drop what costs range, raise what only an EV owner values, and price against the delta rather than the shelf.

Rebuilding the value curveBlue Ocean, four actions

Eliminate and reduce

  • Drag that costs range
  • Cumbersome installation
  • Afterthought aesthetics
  • Ambiguous compliance

Raise and create

  • Wake aware aerodynamics
  • Install once, deploy on demand
  • EV aligned design
  • Compliance documentation
  • E-bike readiness
  • White glove service

Compete on what the category already competes on and the patent is worth nothing. These ten decisions are what makes it a different product rather than a better rack.

What the value is worth, driver by driverRacks todayAuxtail target
  • Range preservation25%3 to 8
  • Ease of installation20%4 to 8
  • Security18%6 to 7
  • Aesthetic integration14%5 to 8
  • Compliance and warranty13%5 to 8
  • Service access10%7 to 8

5.2 to 8.2

+3.0 weighted

And the uplift sits on range and installation, which is what the survey said it cared about. That is the whole argument for the price below.

Priced against the value, fenced by tier

Core

£1,495

The validated pain points, and nothing else

  • Integrated chassis
  • Deployable carrier, 2 bikes
  • Lighting and plate visibility
  • Baseline lock

Performance

£1,795

Families and club riders carrying heavier, higher value bikes

  • Everything in Core
  • Reinforced e-bike load modules
  • Quick assist loading arms
  • Premium trims

Security+

+£149

Buyers whose bikes are worth more than the rack

  • Upgraded locks
  • Anchor mounts
  • Tracker recess

Value based, not cost plus: priced off the PUV delta and the survey's willingness to pay, fenced so you only pay more where you get more. Instalments over 12 to 24 months take the upfront barrier down.

The same silver BMW i4 from behind with no bikes on it. The Auxtail rack is folded flat across the rear bumper, carrying the number plate and its own lights, and reads as part of the car.

Four ways in, one to start with

Auxtail

  • Retail first

    No

    Halfords brings reach and takes the margin with it, and a shop floor cannot sell a drag coefficient. The product gets commoditised next to the racks it is beating.

  • Fleet and institutional

    Later

    Councils and clubs buy in volume, slowly, on price. Wrong first customer for a premium product with no track record.

  • OEM licensing first

    Not yet

    Legitimacy and dealer networks, in exchange for years of approval cycles and testing spend before a single sale. Entering here without consumer proof can stall the venture.

  • D2C with certified installers

    Start here

    Keeps the narrative, the margin and the feedback loop, and a certified installer answers the warranty fear directly. It is also the only route that produces the evidence an OEM will later ask for.

The timeline, with the gate on each

  1. Phase 00 to 3 months

    Seed proof

    10 to 25 units placed across regions, aero and installation data collected and published.

    Gate
    Returns at or under 5%, NPS of 55 or better

  2. Phase 13 to 9 months

    OEM licensing prep

    1 hero EV model targeted, dealer pilots run, licensing and royalty terms negotiated.

    Gate
    Dealer install at or under 45 minutes, warranty events at or under 1%

  3. Phase 29 to 18 months

    Early majority bridge

    2 to 3 more EV models fitted, installer network to 10 to 15 partners, Performance tier launched.

    Gate
    CAC payback within 6 months, installer NPS above 60

The business model, on 1 canvas

Key partners

  • EV makers, for legitimacy and dealer networks
  • Cycling retailers and installers, for reach

Key activities

  • Design and manufacture to aero and compliance standards
  • Direct marketing, clubs and event demos

Value propositions

  • Range kept
  • Easy to fit and remove
  • Looks like part of the EV
  • A system, not a bolt on

Customer relationships

  • Fit check and a pre order waitlist
  • Certified installers
  • Clear warranty and aftercare

Customer segments

  • Affluent EV owning families
  • Cycling and triathlon clubs
  • Later: OEMs, fleets and councils

Key resources

  • The rear integration patent
  • Aero and structural test results
  • The founder's experience

Channels

  • Online configurator and shop
  • Roadshows with EV and cycling clubs
  • Later: OEM dealers and retailers

Cost structure

  • Manufacturing, the largest
  • Marketing and sales
  • R&D for new EV models

Revenue streams

  • Core £1,495 and Performance £1,795
  • Security+ and add ons
  • Installation by certified partners
  • Later: OEM licensing royalties
What could break it, and the answer to each5 risks
  • Warranty

    A failure or a compliance gap undoes trust, and the OEM talks with it.

    Compliance certification packs, and OEMs brought in early.

  • Aero varies by car

    The drag saving may differ from 1 EV shape to the next.

    Test across models, and publish ranges rather than 1 number.

  • Uneven installers

    A poor fitting hurts both satisfaction and safety.

    Certification, standard procedures and ongoing checks.

  • Price resistance

    A premium price meets resistance, even in premium segments.

    Financing, bundles, and showing the value plainly.

  • Supply delays

    Manufacturing ventures run late.

    Dual sourcing, and small pilot batches.

4 numbers to watch

Acquisition
New customers per period, by campaign, event and installer referral.
Satisfaction
NPS, warranty feedback and post install surveys.
Engagement
Use of the configurator, the forums and social media.
Conversion
Prospects who go from awareness to a deposit or a purchase.

Underneath all of it is one sequence: prove it with your own customers, then sell that proof to the people who can scale it. D2C is not the destination. It is how you earn the meeting.

4 key decisions

04What it cost

Every section above says what I recommended and why. None of them says what it costs to be right, so this one does.

01

What is actually being sold

Not taken

A better rack

Shipped

A system, sold on the delta

How I got there

Sold as a rack it fights Thule on price and compatibility, and a patent does not win that fight. So the value curve gets rebuilt instead of the product being re-specified.

What it cost

Buyer
You buy compliance and a fitting, not a box off a shelf.
Operations
6 things to raise or create against 4 to drop, and the 6 are the hard ones.
Business
Every unit now carries a service promise, not just a shipment.
02

Where the price comes from

Not taken

Cost plus, against the shelf

Shipped

£1,495, off the value delta

How I got there

The perceived use value moved 5.2 to 8.2, and the survey's own willingness to pay landed inside £1,500 to £1,800. The price is argued from those 2 numbers rather than from what the shelf charges.

What it cost

Buyer
2x to 2.5x the premium rack sitting next to it.
Operations
Every sale needs the aero and compliance case made, not just stocked.
Business
Small volumes. The launch target is 2,603 people, not a category.
03

Which door to knock on first

Not taken

OEM licensing first

Shipped

Direct, with certified installers

How I got there

OEM first buys legitimacy and a dealer network in exchange for years of approval cycles before a single sale. Entering there without consumer proof can stall the venture.

What it cost

Buyer
An installer visit, not a box that arrives.
Operations
A regional installer network to build, from 0 to 15 partners.
Business
18 months of proving it yourself before the OEM conversation.
04

What to do with the warranty fear

Not taken

A line in the manual

Shipped

A compliance pack you are sold

How I got there

12 of 20 named warranty, and it is not about the rack: they fear that bolting anything to a new EV voids the cover on the car. A footnote does not answer that.

What it cost

Buyer
The thing that removes the fear is also the thing costing you money.
Operations
Lighting, plate visibility, load and aero, tested and documented before launch.
Business
Per model work: 1 hero EV first, then 2 to 3 more behind it.

Auxtail Pitch Deck

058 slides

Everything above, compressed into the artefact it was for: the problem in numbers, the market in 3 tiers, the product, the business model, the ask, and the way out.

Step through with the arrows, the dots, or the left and right keys.

Pitch deck · 01 Title

Title slide. Revolutionizing EV-Cycling Transport, Auxtail. A white BMW i4 on black with 4 mountain bikes carried on a rear-mounted rack. Craig Broadbent, Auxtail Founder and ex-design engineer at Nissan.

What a designer learns doing this

06Reflection, next

I came in as an industrial designer and spent it on what design school leaves out: what it costs, who pays, why anybody says yes. The journal opens on mechanisms and closes on pricing fences, which is the distance travelled.

Evidence beats conviction

4 thresholds went down in writing before the survey went out, so the findings could have killed the positioning. That is the only reason meeting them counts.

The objection is rarely the product

Nobody doubted the rack. They doubted their warranty, their range and the install, and the strategy answers those 3 while the hardware barely changed.

Outside forces shape the product

Regulation caps the load at 70kg, OEM approval sets the clock, retail takes the margin. 3 parties shaped this product before a customer ever saw it.

Pricing is a design decision

A tier is a fence: what sits inside it, and what a buyer has to want badly enough to cross it. That is drawing, not accounting.

A patent is not a business

The engineering was finished and protected before I arrived. Everything between that and somebody paying for it was still missing, and it was the harder half.

The whole cycle, end to end

Costs, margins, channels and gates, and how they move each other. Knowing that is what lets me sit between engineering, finance and sales and use each one's words.

Next is Phase 0: 10 to 25 units in real driveways, the aero and install data published, and that evidence taken to pre seed funds and mobility accelerators. Everything above is a plan until somebody's bikes are on the back of their own car.

The project

  • Deepakkrishna Ramachandran

    Project owner, commercial strategy

  • Ali Junaid Ahmad

    Project mentor, course leader MSc IAE, WMG

  • Craig Broadbent

    Auxtail founder, ex-design engineer at Nissan

A grey Nissan Qashqai parked at the edge of a sandy forest track, carrying 1 mountain bike on the Auxtail rack, with the rack's own lighting board and AUXTAIL plate below the bike.